Which dining chairs?

Help us pick ~ please!  Two out of three of our antique chairs have fallen apart in the last month.  We want to purchase three chairs for one side of the table and put the black arm chairs on the ends (with new fabric seats). We have several that we like.  Each of us has our own favorites, of course. 

First, here is our table ~ 

Pine, farmhouse style, tapered legs, very simple, dark wood knots that add lots of character.

Second, a distressed pine wood bench that our kids have been sitting at since they could climb up there.  It's a permanent piece in our house for sentimental reasons.

Lastly,  black Napoleon style chairs that my hubby really doesn't like but they are staying for budget reasons and because we want to have a mismatched look.

I believe we have narrowed it down to three choices.  So cast your votes and help us decide.

Choice #1

Crate & Barrel Delta

1950's aluminum bargain at $99 each

coordinate with barstools in kitchen that we love

Choice #2

Pottery Barn Isabella

cute and colorful

one each of red, green, and brown

$139 each

Choice #3

Pottery Barn Stella

in mahogany stain

classic, simple, but most expensive at $199 each

 

Keep in mind that our house has some contemporary accents like keyless light fixtures and interior barn doors but we also have traditional furniture. 

 Take a stroll through the house if you want.

The living, dining, and kitchen are all completly open to each other, so keep that in mind too.

And when you know which you would pick, comment below or vote in the poll in the sidebar.

Thanks, blog friends!